
-------Concise Lesson--------
1) Don't ask things just for the sake of asking them.
2) Forget expectations. All that matters now is what is real.
3) The story will unfold by itself.
-------Backstory--------
You think that maybe- just maybe- you actually understand stuff.
Not even necessarily calculus stuff, maybe politics stuff or social stuff or just stuff stuff in general, and then:
You find yourself running out of questions.
That sounded quite philosophical, didn't it? Well, it wasn't supposed to be. It was real. Today in Teen Court I was prosecuting, questioning a 13-year-old defendent who'd taken prescription drugs in class and had to be hospitalized.
So I started off my second line of quesitoning with, "I hear your teacher had to call the nurse in the middle of class. Er...is that correct?"
So I started off my second line of quesitoning with, "I hear your teacher had to call the nurse in the middle of class. Er...is that correct?"
Okay, first mistake: That was a statement. Not a question.
Second mistake: I didn't "hear" it. I read it in the police report! Immediately after I said that, I started thinking, What the heck was that? Why did that come out of my mouth?! Now I sound like some farmer down at the tavern, or a guidance conselour or something. (Yes, I do realize that those are nothing alike, and apologize for my obscure metaphor-like sentence.)
Anyway, we struggled past that and I got to, "So why did she call the nurse?"
He answered with, "Because I was sleeping."
Here, unfortunately, I got waaaay off track. I should have asked something like "had you taken pills that made you sleepy?", but what I ended up asking was, "And why were you sleeping?"
This left an opening for the extrordinarily uncooperative young defendent to say, "Because I was tired."
I don't really remember or want to remember what happened next, but what I do know is that I screwed up royally. Still, my co-counsel C saved both our butts majorly with her clear, pulled-together opener and closers and we got exactly the consequences we asked for. It didn't hurt that the defendent was rather dislikeable (and completely unremorseful) either.
(Strangely, this was the first time I've seen a jury actually pay attention. No one was texting. No one was even zoning out! The one kid who I thought was just lazing around asked a very relevent question at the end. This is majorly awesome, with the minor problem that we had explained to our attorney mentor, a newly-accepted-to-the-bar DA and first-time Teen Court counsel, that the jury never listens. And honestly, they usually don't. I was shocked. Another lesson learned- don't brag about experience until you've seen it all.)
As the jury was deliberating, both C and a Teen Court manager commented that I had done well, but needed to learn to "think on my feet" a bit more. I nodded emphatically. So...
Just how do I learn to think on my feet?!
Here's what I came up with:
1) Don't ask things for the sake of asking them. When asking questions, don't just ask for the sake of asking. This applies not only to Teen Court, where I asked "Why did she call the nurse?" simply to get the answer of "I had taken muscle relaxants but ended up so relaxed I couldn't stay awake". It also applies to the real world. "How are you doing?" has become like "Hello". We don't expect an answer.
But maybe we should.
Maybe we should really, really listen for that answer, because then- if I'm not just waiting for stuff to come out of his mouth so that I can ask the next question- maybe then I'll be more sure-footed in my own mind. It'll become easier to leapfrog to the next question depending on his answer.
2) Forget expectations. I expected the defendent to answer with...something he didn't answer with. And then I got so hung up on getting to that one right answer that I became very unflexible and confusing, asking unnessecary questions. What's important isn't what he should answer, it's what he does answer. From there, I think I just need to tell myself to relax and ask logical follow-up questions.
3) The story unfolds by itself. Just Teen Court - wise... I hope I can remember in the future that I'm not trying to coax a certain answer out of the defendent. Our DA mentor today, T, explained it in a way that I absolutely understood at the time and have absolutely forgotten now, but it was something like this... "We're telling a story- that's the job of a lawyer." You're calling these characters up and what you want is to get them to tell their part of the story in a way that meshes with your part of the story. Don't think like a rigid flow-chart of "if he answers A, then C, but if he answers B, than D and E or maybe F if he mentions G..." Leave it open. Don't stress about it. As wise old Lewis Carrol wrote,
"Take care of the sense and the sounds will take care of themselves."
If you can hold the meaning you want to reach firmly in mind, then the questions and answers will flow naturally.
No comments:
Post a Comment