So andrococo posted something called "10 Things Men Can Do to Stop Domestic Violence," and I agreed (or didn't have a problem with) the entire list up till this:
8. Stop supporting the notion that domestic and
sexual violence is due to mental illness, lack of anger
management skills, chemical dependency, stress, etc… Domestic
and sexual violence is rooted in male dominance and the
socialization of men.
The "notion"? It's often the truth. I wouldn't have a problem with this except that I was reading a book called...hm...The Devil's Dozen, I think, because it was in with the law books, and it was all about serial killers (which I'm brainstorming a short story about). All of the killers listed in the book were male, and many of their crimes involved extreme sexual violence due to mental illness. Just as you cannot argue that people should "get over" depression, you cannot argue that these killers killed out of the "socialization of men." They were sick, twisted bastards who were absolutely not right in the head. Sexual violence may stem from simply a wish to hurt, a belief that men are superior to women, etc. etc. and in those cases it is NEVER an excuse. Actually, there's no excuse at all. But frankly, it is ridiculous to say that violence is never due to alcoholism ("chemical dependency), mental illness, or stress (often some combination of the three). Again, I'm not saying that because these are the causes, violence of any kind is acceptable. I'm merely saying you cannot simply blame the traditional role of men in society for creating violence and sexual violence.
Also: The serial murders are an extreme case. I just wanted to point out that mental illness can lead to violence, especially violence that discriminates against one type of person (ie, all the victims were women).
P.S. In case you hadn't noticed, my hobby is playing Devil's Advocate. I don't know why I do it. It's fun. If you're outright blaming somebody for something, to the point that you won't even bother to try to empathize or understand, I'm going to try to find holes in your argument. I got really mad about that "stupid immature little bastard who's whining about his unborn child, get over yourself, you would have abandoned the kid anyway" thing. So I stood up for the guy. I would have stood up for the girl's choice if you had started saying all that kind of crap about her, and empathizing indiscriminately with the guy. I hate it when people make the world all black or all white.
It's funny, because if I just read the paragraph above, I sound like I should be a defense attorney. I don't know. I think I could be, but I hope I never have to be.
As always, if you disagree with me, I'd love to hear why. I wouldn't love to hear "Shut up" or "That's stupid" or "You're a fucking idiot," all of which I have heard before. I try to express my views reasonably and clearly and politely. If I haven't, let me know and I'll try to fix it. I like open debates. I don't like being cussed out because someone can't be bothered to think calmly about why they believe the things they do and then put their views into words.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment